A collection curated by the students of English 235 at Wheaton College in Norton, Massachusetts.
Showing posts with label Fall 2014. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fall 2014. Show all posts
Wednesday, November 5, 2014
The Knights Errant Part 2
As mentioned in the previous post, the Knight's Errant that we see today was not what Sir John Everett Millais originally painted. In his original painting the woman was facing the knight, because of this, many believed this expressed the woman's 'loose morals'. In response to this, Millais cut out the torso of the woman and repainted it to have her looking away from the knight, showing modesty.
The original cut out torso of the woman was reused for another of Millais' paintings 'The Martyr of The Solway'
Labels:
1870s,
Chivalry,
Fall 2014,
Oil Painting,
Sir John Everett Millais,
The Moonstone
Wednesday, October 29, 2014
The Knight's Errant
Overall
This
oil painting depicts a typical chivalrous knight helping a damsel in distress.
In this almost life sized painting, an armor clad knight is freeing a
stripped, defenseless women who was attacked and kidnapped. The knight’s sword
is covered in blood and the assumed attacker’s corpse can be seen behind him. The
tree the woman is tied to is a Silver birch, which at the time, was identified
with the female gender; being referred to as “Lady Birch”.
About the Artist
The
artist: Sir John Everett, Millais was born June 8th 1829. He was a
child prodigy; he attended Sass's Art School in London and won a silver medal
at the Society of Arts at the age of nine.
Reception
Because of the female nudity of the
painting, it was given very critical reviews.
A lot of this critic was on Millais’ treatment of the woman. Critics thought that this was an attempt to
idealize nudity and place it in a classical (Greek or Roman) setting. Millais
was actually trying emulate an early Victorian style of painting started by
artist William Etty. Etty’s was known for his nude paintings but what Millais
really admired was the techniques and rich colors Etty used. Stangely enough
one of the main critics of the paintings was that the woman was too
“life-like”. “the manner is almost too real for the treatment of the nude” (quoted
in Nead p.235 of the June 1870 Art Journal). Not only that but some questioned the woman’s
morals. Because of this as well as the fact that the painting wasn’t selling,
Millais cut the head and torso off the painting. He then repainted the woman to
be looking way to make her appear more modest. The portion of the painting cut
out was reused in another painting a year later. After the revision, the
painting was sold in 1874.
How it Connects to empire
The first thing is the controversy
that was caused by the nudity of the woman. Due to the more conserved nature of
the English more importantly English women, nudity was mostly connected with
savages. Although it is made clear in the painting that the woman was nude
because she was attacked, critics still questioned and assumed the woman’s
morals.
Next is the literal name of the
painting. The Knight’s Errant is the
adventure a knight goes on in search of people to help. This can be somewhat
connected to how the English “help” other countries such as India. Because the
English identify themselves as basically the ‘pinnacle of society’ it is their
duty to help others. One of these means of “help” would be the missionaries
that went around spreading (forcing) Christianity onto others. Similar to Ms.
Clack in the Moonstone
Work Cited
- Virag, Rebecca.
"Sir John Everett Millais, Bt, 'The Knight Errant' 1870." Tate.
N.p., Mar. 2001. Web. 20 Oct. 2014.
- Riggs, Terry.
"Sir John Everett Millais, Bt, 'Ophelia' 1851-2." Tate.
N.p., Jan. 1998. Web. 20 Oct. 2014.
Labels:
1870s,
Chivalry,
Fall 2014,
Oil Painting,
Sir John Everett Millais,
The Moonstone
Artifact of Empire 1880s
"The Nemesis of Neglect"
What
is it?
This artifact is an illustration of the infamous
serial killer Jack the Ripper, the serial killer who terrorized the streets of
Whitechapel in the year 1888. In this depiction, Jack is portrayed like a
ghost, haunting the neighborhood; he is transparent and floating as well as
having a ghoulish visage which depicts him as inhuman rather than as an
ordinary person (because of this, he becomes more of a character than any
person out loose on the streets of London). He is even described as a “phantom”
and “spectre” in the picture’s caption. His cape – which symbolically serves as
a veil of his identity – is branded with the text “CRIME,” a generalization
which pictures Jack as only one aspect of the crime within London, not as the
only source of it no matter how astonishing his crimes may be. His background also hints at there being a
problem with the bigger picture of London and extending it beyond one brutal murderer.
The street is drawn as dark and unfriendly with broken bottles of what looks to
be alcohol and shattered plates littering the streets while windows are either
shattered or boarded up, portraying the nasty conditions of Whitechapel and the
lack of care and notice taken for the area up until this point. Lastly, the
ghoulish Jack is shown as being able to walk right up to the doorsteps of this
neighborhood brandishing a rather large sharpened blade. This all ties in with
the bolded title “NEMESIS OF NEGLECT” at the image’s base; the illustration
censures the neglect Britain has for the poor neighborhoods such as Whitechapel
and actively characterizes a nameless threat as a predator on this negligence
in order to emphasize the real threat: Britain’s neglect.
Context
The illustration provides readers of Punch with a reason to question the
wholesome Christian Empire that Britain portrayed itself to be during the
Victorian Age. As with the previous decades, the Empire set itself on a
pedestal as the prime example of order and prestige. Punch satirizes the horror of the five gory Whitechapel murders to
ridicule Britain’s control over their own nation and criticize the way the
Empire pictures itself. Upon looking at this image, however, readers do not see
order let alone anything to be proud of. The portrayal of the Ripper as a ghost
not only paints him as mysterious and haunting but also as elusive; for an
empire in control of colonies extending into the Orient and in possession of a
great deal of power, it is disgraceful, as portrayed here, that it cannot catch
even one fiend such as Jack the Ripper who went as far as taunting police with
gruesome notes recounting his pleasure taken in slaughtering the five women.
Punch
also criticizes the juxtaposition between how Britain boasts itself to be and
the reality of life in the Empire. The setting of the illustration is not
something to be proud of; in fact, the streets of Whitechapel have been known
to have been the homes to many shifty and/or impoverished characters at the
time, many of which were also immigrants. The five victims had been known as
drinkers and morally questionable, and Mary Kelly had emigrated from Ireland
before she had been slaughtered in her own residence. Also, she was the only
one of the five to be brutalized inside and not in the streets, another detail
to shock the public; not only had “CRIME” invaded their streets but it had also
entered their households and brought along an onslaught of overkill and
mutilation. This horror serves as a great contrast to the highly moral
character the Empire prided itself in at the time, countering Victorian Values
with Jack’s bloody reign of terror.
The satire of Punch in relation to this image serves to show the duplicity and
deception of the British Empire which used such cunning moves to advance its
influence in the world. One on hand there is the caring Christian nation
spreading its values to the “unfortunate” Orient with missionaries and their
values, but on the other remains the nation itself which has plummeted into a
state of chaos and terror all while the Empire denies the world of this truth.
How
Does it Relate to What We’ve Read in Class?
The reason this image applies to
Robert Louis Stevenson’s The Strange Case
of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and is included as part of Appendix J is that
there are strong parallels to the motif of duplicity and hidden dark sides in
both cases. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde both symbolize a different side of the British
Empire. Jekyll represents how Britain portrays itself; both have good
reputations and relations within society and serve as helpers to man (in
Jekyll’s case, he is a doctor and a healer whereas Britain is a missionary). In
contrast, Hyde represents how the facts and cases such as Jack the Ripper’s
portray Britain; both Hyde and the Empire step on the innocence of others to
get where they are going. On page 33 of the narrative, Hyde “trampled calmly
over the child’s body;” here, the child symbolizes innocence which is being
overlooked in order for Hyde to heartlessly continue with his own plan. Britain
may also be described as a “Juggernaut” (33) over the Orient, preying upon the
innocence and lesser strength of the nation to conquer land in order to preserve
its values and power. This connects to Darwin’s idea of adaptation with Britain
adapting to its role as a great force in the Victorian Era and having the
Orient fall behind as the region struggles to adapt to Britain’s force,
technology, and scientific advances.
The setting of the image also
parallels the description of Soho given on page 48 of Stevenson’s narrative.
The “rugged children huddled in the doorways, and many women of many different
nationalities” reflects the conditions of Whitechapel and the sorts of people
found there. These doorsteps mentioned are picture in the image above and, by
connecting both the passage and the image, it is implied that these women,
children, and nationalities are at risk due to the neglect Britain places on
the poor and foreign. Punch and
Stevenson heavily emphasize the dual identity of the Empire in these ways,
portraying Britain like a bold missionary on the outside but a neglectful
parent to its people on the other.
Other Artifacts
"With the Vigilance Committee in theEast End" from the Illustrated London News on October 13, 1888 (http://www.historytoday.com/william-d-rubinstein/hunt-jack-ripper)
Citations
Stevenson, Robert Louis, and Martin A. Danahay. The
Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.2nd ed. Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview
Press, 2005. Print.
"The Nemesis of Neglect." Punch
29 Sept. 1888: 152. Print.
Other Sources
"Europe PubMed Central." The Whitechapel murders: the case of Jack
the Ripper.. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Oct. 2014. <http://europepmc.org/abstract/MED/7030054>.
"Punch." Google Books. N.p., n.d. Web. 27
Oct. 2014. <http://books.google.com/books?id=MAYDAAAAIAAJ&pg=RA1-PA102&dq=punch+september+1888&hl=en&sa=X&ei=TAhIVIOOBpPnsASIo4GYCg&ved=0CEsQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=nemesis%20neglect&f=false>.
Handkerchief of Empire
What is it?
My artifact is a handkerchief that was made to commemorate the Diamond Jubilee of Queen Victoria, an event that marked the sixtieth anniversary of her reign. The handkerchief is made from linen and is embellished with a black roller print design, indicating that it was probably mass-produced to be bought by all socio-economic classes. The design of the handkerchief depicts the British Empire and her various technological inventions through a series of icons laid out in concentric circles. Outside the outermost circle are coats of arms representing the imperial holdings of Canada, India, Australia, and Africa. Within the outermost circle are icons symbolizing the major industrial inventions of the nineteenth century. The inventions represented here include the railroad, the printing machine, the telegraph, the Maxim gun, and the battleship, the HMS Majestic. Finally, the innermost circle depicts Queen Victoria herself.
Context
The imagery on the handkerchief tells a triumphant story of British imperial might. First, the design of concentric circles evokes the globe, a reminder that British power extended to all corners of the earth in 1897. By having Queen Victoria in the center circle and the British colonies at the periphery of the outer circle, the handkerchief reinforces the idea that Queen Victoria—and, by extension, Great Britain—was the central authority overseeing the far reaches of the British Empire. The outer circle, which depicts British technological innovations, gives a sense of how British power was maintained despite the vast oceans separating England and her colonies. The telegraph and printing press, for instance, opened more efficient lines of communication between England and her imperial holdings. As the historian Ronald Hyam notes about the telegraph in particular, “The one triumphantly unifying factor [of the empire] was cable construction...: ‘the nerves of the empire’, by the 1890s, girdled the world with 121,000 miles of telegraph wires.” In a similar manner, technologies of travel such as the railway strengthened British power abroad by making it easier for government agents and soldiers to reach colonial outposts quickly and efficiently. The Maxim gun and the HMS Majestic shown on the handkerchief symbolize the unrivalled military might of Britain during this time period. For instance, the Maxim gun, a machine gun described as “frightfully destructive” by its inventor, changed the face of imperial warfare. Emily S. Rosenberg observes that the gun “emerged as a potent weapon in ‘little wars’ that were fought on colonial frontiers, where small British forces sought to imprint their authority over large areas and the substantial armies that tribal leaders could muster.” In sum, this commemorative handkerchief functions as a piece of imperial propaganda. It celebrates territorial conquests made by Britain, and details those inventions which permitted the further expansion and consolidation of the British Empire.
How Does it Relate to Nineteenth-Century Literature?
The handkerchief’s representation of imperial might, I believe, resonates with Rudyard Kipling’s depiction of empire in “The White Man’s Burden.” Kipling alludes to the violence involved in maintaining imperial power when he writes, “Take up the White Man’s burden--/ The savage wars of peace” (lines 17-18). Similarly, the Maxim gun and the HMS Majestic on the handkerchief reminds one of the horrific violence and destruction involved in maintaining British authority over her colonies. Furthermore, I see a relationship between Kipling’s depiction of colonized people as “silent” (line 47) and the fact that Africa, India, Australia, and Canada are represented by their coats of arms on the handkerchief. By representing these territories by their British-bestowed symbols, the handkerchief works to “silence” the voices of colonized people. In other words, the indigenous cultures of Africa, India, Australia, and Canada are not represented in the handkerchief’s narrative of empire; rather, these cultures are symbolically assimilated into British culture and British political structures. However, there is a crucial difference in tone between Kipling’s depiction of empire and the handkerchief’s. Where Kipling appears to critique practices of imperialism in his poem, the handkerchief unapologetically celebrates empire and imperialism.
Works Cited
My artifact is a handkerchief that was made to commemorate the Diamond Jubilee of Queen Victoria, an event that marked the sixtieth anniversary of her reign. The handkerchief is made from linen and is embellished with a black roller print design, indicating that it was probably mass-produced to be bought by all socio-economic classes. The design of the handkerchief depicts the British Empire and her various technological inventions through a series of icons laid out in concentric circles. Outside the outermost circle are coats of arms representing the imperial holdings of Canada, India, Australia, and Africa. Within the outermost circle are icons symbolizing the major industrial inventions of the nineteenth century. The inventions represented here include the railroad, the printing machine, the telegraph, the Maxim gun, and the battleship, the HMS Majestic. Finally, the innermost circle depicts Queen Victoria herself.
Context
The imagery on the handkerchief tells a triumphant story of British imperial might. First, the design of concentric circles evokes the globe, a reminder that British power extended to all corners of the earth in 1897. By having Queen Victoria in the center circle and the British colonies at the periphery of the outer circle, the handkerchief reinforces the idea that Queen Victoria—and, by extension, Great Britain—was the central authority overseeing the far reaches of the British Empire. The outer circle, which depicts British technological innovations, gives a sense of how British power was maintained despite the vast oceans separating England and her colonies. The telegraph and printing press, for instance, opened more efficient lines of communication between England and her imperial holdings. As the historian Ronald Hyam notes about the telegraph in particular, “The one triumphantly unifying factor [of the empire] was cable construction...: ‘the nerves of the empire’, by the 1890s, girdled the world with 121,000 miles of telegraph wires.” In a similar manner, technologies of travel such as the railway strengthened British power abroad by making it easier for government agents and soldiers to reach colonial outposts quickly and efficiently. The Maxim gun and the HMS Majestic shown on the handkerchief symbolize the unrivalled military might of Britain during this time period. For instance, the Maxim gun, a machine gun described as “frightfully destructive” by its inventor, changed the face of imperial warfare. Emily S. Rosenberg observes that the gun “emerged as a potent weapon in ‘little wars’ that were fought on colonial frontiers, where small British forces sought to imprint their authority over large areas and the substantial armies that tribal leaders could muster.” In sum, this commemorative handkerchief functions as a piece of imperial propaganda. It celebrates territorial conquests made by Britain, and details those inventions which permitted the further expansion and consolidation of the British Empire.
![]() |
| The Maxim machine-gun was adopted by the British Army in 1889. |
How Does it Relate to Nineteenth-Century Literature?
The handkerchief’s representation of imperial might, I believe, resonates with Rudyard Kipling’s depiction of empire in “The White Man’s Burden.” Kipling alludes to the violence involved in maintaining imperial power when he writes, “Take up the White Man’s burden--/ The savage wars of peace” (lines 17-18). Similarly, the Maxim gun and the HMS Majestic on the handkerchief reminds one of the horrific violence and destruction involved in maintaining British authority over her colonies. Furthermore, I see a relationship between Kipling’s depiction of colonized people as “silent” (line 47) and the fact that Africa, India, Australia, and Canada are represented by their coats of arms on the handkerchief. By representing these territories by their British-bestowed symbols, the handkerchief works to “silence” the voices of colonized people. In other words, the indigenous cultures of Africa, India, Australia, and Canada are not represented in the handkerchief’s narrative of empire; rather, these cultures are symbolically assimilated into British culture and British political structures. However, there is a crucial difference in tone between Kipling’s depiction of empire and the handkerchief’s. Where Kipling appears to critique practices of imperialism in his poem, the handkerchief unapologetically celebrates empire and imperialism.
Works Cited
- Ronald Hyam, Understanding the British Empire (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010), 19.
- Qtd. in J. Bucknall Smith, “Illustrated Interviews: No. XXXVIII—Mr. Hiram S. Maxim,” The Strand Magazine, 8 (July-December 1894), 584.
- Emily S. Rosenberg, A World Connecting: 1870-1945 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press & C.H. Beck Verlag, 2012), 359.
More Information
Handkerchief.
Creator unknown. Made in Britain, 1897. Found on ArtStor.org.
From: The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Scarf from Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee
![]() |
| Artifact: Commemorative Scarf from Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee. Date: 1897 Producer: Unknown Material: White china silk |
What is it?
The
artifact I chose is a scarf made in 1897 that was intended to commemorate Queen
Victoria’s Diamond Jubilee. The manufacturer of the artifact is unknown but the
scarf is made from white china silk. The center of the scarf depicts three
images of Queen Victoria. One portrait is from the beginning of her reign, one
is from the middle, and one is from the time of the Jubilee. There is script
above and below these images. The top portion reads “Her Gracious Majesty
Victoria” and the portion below reads, “Queen of Great Britain and Empress of
India”. Along the border of the scarf are the names of the 24 countries that
were members of the British Empire at the time. A particular focus is given to
India, England, Scotland, and Ireland as these countries make up the corners
and are particularly embellished with decorative coats of arms.
Context
The
Diamond Jubilee was an event celebrated not just in England, but
internationally as well. It took place on June 22, 1897 and was a 6-mile
procession through the streets of London featuring 17 carriages and
representatives from all of Victoria’s dominion countries. Particularly
prominent were the Indian cavalry that escorted Victoria’s carriage. In short,
the event was a blatant display of imperialism, as Victoria literally paraded
her colonies around London in an attempt to show her people, and the rest of
the world, how strong the British Empire actually was.
The images presented on the scarf
symbolically reflect these ideas of imperialism and British power. Victoria
herself serves as the focal point of the scarf, indicating that she remains the
most important part of the empire. In addition, laurel wreaths surround her
images and she is depicted wearing crowns and jewelry, reflecting the Empire’s
wealth and prosperity. In contrast, the colonies are shown on the outer borders
of the scarf, indicating that they are of lesser importance than England. It is
also interesting to note which countries were positioned in the corners of the
scarf. Scotland, England, Ireland, and India were given special attention and
the designs for these countries are especially ornate. It’s possible that these
countries were seen as the most relevant and important colonies to England.
Scotland and Ireland are close to England geographically and have long
histories with England so it makes sense that the English would see them as important.
India, however, was a fairly recent acquisition, Victoria was crowned Empress
of India in 1877, but it was still seen as important enough to take up a corner
of the scarf. This is because India was seen as the “jewel in the crown” and
was highly valued by England for the resources it provided. Interestingly, one
of the most valued resources extracted from India was silk, since India had
access to silk from China. Ironically, this scarf is made from silk that was
probably from India. So this scarf, which portrays the imperialistic
relationship between England and India, is made from a resource received
directly from that imperialism.
By creating this scarf and then
selling it as a souvenir, the manufacturer effectively trivializes the
important issues associated with imperialism. England was proud of their
colonies and viewed them as possessions, ignoring the harmful effects that
their influence had on the colonies. The English were so proud of their vast
empire that they purchased and wore a scarf that bragged about their colonial
acquisitions.
Relation to Text
In
a general sense, the ideas of imperialism represented in the scarf relate to
the themes of imperialism that are present in all of the texts we’ve read in
the course. Specifically, it connects with The
Moonstone, as that novel criticizes the imperialistic relationship between
England and India. In the novel, most of the story takes place in England,
which reaffirms the assertion on the scarf that England is the central and most
important part of the empire. There could also be a connection between the
actual Moonstone, which is a cursed Indian jewel, and the idea that India was
considered “the jewel in the crown”. In The
Moonstone, the jewel is extremely important and valued in India for its
religious importance. However, when the English take it, it becomes cursed and
is the center of a crime scene. Perhaps Collins is playing with the metaphor of
India being a jewel but is suggesting a darker relationship between the two
countries. While Collins criticizes the imperial relationship between England
and India, the scarf does the opposite.
I also see a relationship between
the ideas presented in the scarf and the philosophy of Herbert Spencer. Spencer
argued that it was natural for societies to grow more complex and advanced with
time. He writes, “The orderly progress from simplicity to complexity, displayed
by bodies-politic in common with living bodies, is a characteristic which
distinguishes living bodies from the inanimate bodies amid which they move”
(Spencer 9). He claims it is “orderly”
for societies to become more complex. He later distinguishes between savage and
civilized societies, arguing that civilized societies continue to grow, “In
complexity, our large civilized nations as much exceed primitive savage tribes”
(Spencer 9). The imagery on the scarf seems to agree with this idea. Spencer’s
theory somewhat justifies the ideas of imperialism. It is likely that the
British saw their massive and always expanding empire as natural and even a
sign of civilization. If they believed this, then it would have been easy to
justify wearing a scarf that blatantly promoted imperialism.
Artifact Link: http://0-library.artstor.org.helin.uri.edu/library/welcome.html#3%7Csearch%7C6%7CAll20Collections3A20victoria20diamond20jubilee%7CFiltered20Search%7C%7C%7Ctype3D3626kw3Dvictoria20diamond20jubilee7Call26geoIds3D26clsIds3D26collTypes3D26id3Dall26bDate3D26eDate3D26dExact3D26prGeoId3D26origKW3Dvictoria20diamond20jubilee7Call
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









